Silencing the HTPC

The Antec Fusion Black HTPC case has two of their TriCool fans, which provide a three-position switch for speed selection. They flow tremendous amounts of air, but even at their lowest setting they're audible, and they're not controllable by the motherboard.

Antec TriCool fan performance

RPM CFM dB
2000 79 30
1600 56 28
1200 39 25

In order for the motherboard to control a fan, it must have a three-pin connector. This provides voltage and ground, plus a sensor wire to sense the fan speed. Many fans provide only a four-pin Molex connector, which won't allow for any motherboard control.

This excellent fan comparison led me to order a pair of Scythe S-Flex fans. The fan features "Fluid Dynamic Bearings" licensed from Sony, and is available quite cheaply. The fans are available in three model designations, -D, -E, and -F, indicating low, medium, and high-speed, respectively.

Scythe S-Flex fan performance

Model RPM CFM dB
SFF21D 800rpm 33.5CFM 8.7dBA
SFF21E 1,200rpm 49.0CFM 20.1dBA
SFF21F 1,600rpm 63.7CFM 28.0dBA

I bought the fastest of the three available with the optimistic hope that my Biostar mother board will do a reasonable job of regulating their actual speed as needed to control temperatures.

Update

I have since learned that the TF7050-M2 apparently cannot control the speed of case fans. The -F model is exactly as loud as you would expect a 30-ish-dB fan, which is far too loud for a home theater PC. So, I stopped by Central Computer and overpaid for the -D model (800rpm). It's still audible three feet away, but I'm sure I'll never hear it once it's in the entertainment center cabinet.

About Jeff Fitzsimons

Jeff Fitzsimons is a software engineer in the California Bay Area. Technical specialties include C++, Win32, and multithreading. Personal interests include rock climbing, cycling, motorcycles, and photography.
This entry was posted in Technology and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *